Advertising
seattlepi.com
NWclassifieds | NWsource | Subscribe | Contact Us | Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Jump to:  Weather | Traffic | Mariners | Seahawks | Sonics | Forums | Calendar
SPECIAL REPORTS ?

OUR AFFILIATES
NWsource
KOMO
Pacific Publishing
MSNBC
Thursday, February 26, 1998

THE POWER TO HARM

Disclosures in this report:

  • Children said to have been sexually abused say actions by police and state workers caused them the most pain.

  • Parents who sought state help with troublesome children found themselves wrongly accused.

  • In at least one case, parents who have won the right to a new trial still worry the state will place their children for adoption before they can clear their names.

  • At least two children taken from their families for protection by the state were subsequently abused in foster homes.
  • 'They robbed me of my childhood'
    Family split apart

    Back to previous page

    Karen Lopez, 32, saw her entire family -- elderly father, her timid, mentally retarded stepmother, brothers, sisters and cousins -- systematically disappear as each was accused by Perez and CPS.

    Small wonder, she says, since her youngest half-sister, Donna -- then Perez's foster daughter -- was encouraged by CPS to manipulate and accuse. Lopez's other half-sister, Melinda, made similar accusations but later recanted.

    "These children were fine until CPS got ahold of them," Lopez says of her two youngest sisters. For years before Perez came knocking, the only problem in the family had been their dad's heavy hand in spanking with a belt, Lopez says.

    But Wenatchee CPS workers didn't like the way the family lived in a small house littered with hand-me-downs, Lopez said. They didn't seem to believe poor people could provide love and care for their children, she said.

    Lopez found herself under investigation in August 1995, when Perez turned up at her home with a driving under the influence arrest warrant for her. She was released when it was determined the warrant was a mistake, but Perez was back the next day with an accusation of child rape.

    Spoiling to take on the system that had destroyed her family, Lopez refused to accept plea bargains and remained behind bars. After she had spent five months in jail, Chelan County Prosecutor Gary Riesen buckled and dismissed the child rape charges.

    But the damage was done.

    "I used to be a person who would go and visit people, say 'Hi' on the street. I don't do that anymore. I stay in my house. I don't let my son associate with anybody. I used to be involved in my son's school, but now I don't even volunteer," she says.

    Moreover, Lopez says CPS placed her now 8-year-old son in a foster home while she was in jail. There, she says, the boy was molested. Weary of trusting the state, she declined to pursue charges and has since moved out of state with him.

    "After what has happened to us, we just don't trust people anymore," she says. "When I was arrested and taken from him, he was petrified and frightened for five months. Now he screams when I go somewhere."

    Photo of Holt
    Laura Holt
     
    Laura Holt, 37, wishes she never signed the confession and accepted the deal Perez offered her in 1994. She says he told her that she would get 50 years in prison and never see her children again unless she admitted molesting them.

    Chelan County Superior Court Judge John Bridges dismissed complaints of coercion, however, and she was sentenced to 40 years. And on a date burned into her mind, Jan. 17, 1996, the state took away her kids anyway.

    "I remember the day, I'll never forget it," she says in a soft Oklahoma accent, her voice quivering. "All three were taken away and permanently adopted out. They're now in three different homes in Wenatchee.

    "I have not seen them since I went to prison in June 1994," she adds.

    Holt's family had long been troubled. In 1993, she accused her husband, Selid, of molesting their 9-year-old daughter. The allegation followed an argument during which Laura Holt accused Selid of seeing another woman. He responded that he was not only having sex with that woman and but also the Holts' daughter. He is now serving a prison sentence.

    But Holt says she was outraged when CPS took her children from school and placed them in foster homes. The caseworkers told her she could keep her kids if she improved her parenting skills, divorced her husband and got her family into counseling with therapist Cindy Andrews.

    Holt says CPS frowned when she instead signed up at the East Wenatchee Mental Health Clinic. CPS steered her to Andrews, whom she says inflicted more harm than good by behaving more like a prosecutor than a therapist.

    "Cindy Andrews told my baby boy before my November 1994 hearing that his momma and daddy was dead," Holt said. "She asked my kids right in front of me whether momma should be in jail with their daddy . . . She argued with my children that they weren't remembering. She kept telling me I did this abuse, that I let my husband hurt my daughter and I had to be involved in it somehow."

    Andrews declined to comment through her attorney.

    Next page: A mother's life changes
    INSIDE SEATTLEPI.COM

    Day in Pictures

    Bruce Springsteen and more

    Fremont Zombie Pub Crawl

    Ghastly night out in Seattle

    Jonathan Demme

    Talks about 'Rachel Getting Married'
    ADVERTISING
      IN THIS SECTION
    · Introduction
    · History
    · The Case
    · The Investigator
    · The Therapy
    ·
    The Children
    · The Accused
    · The Advocates
    · The Context
    · The Probe
    · The Aftermath
    · Editorials
    · Reactions
     
    Advertising
    OUR AFFILIATES
    NWsource KOMO
    Pacific Publishing

    Seattle Post-Intelligencer
    101 Elliott Ave. W.
    Seattle, WA 98119
    (206) 448-8000

    Home Delivery: (206) 464-2121 or (800) 542-0820
    seattlepi.com serves about 1.7 million unique visitors
    and 30 million page views each month.

    Send comments to newmedia@seattlepi.com
    Send investigative tips to iteam@seattlepi.com
    ©1996-2008 Seattle Post-Intelligencer
    Terms of Use/Privacy Policy

    Hearst Newspapers